Which Christmas Tree Should I Buy? Balsam Fir vs. Fraser Fir
Choosing a Christmas tree comes down to a few simple lifestyle questions. Before you head to the lot, think through these:
What’s the ceiling height in the room where the tree will be displayed?
Do you have heavy or oversized ornaments that need extra support?
Do you want a strong holiday fragrance to fill the room, or something more subtle?
Once you know what matters most in your home, it becomes much easier to narrow down the perfect tree.
At Stew Leonard’s, we carry two premium varieties that check all the boxes for beauty, aroma, and long lasting freshness.
Fraser Fir
The Fraser Fir is Stew's best seller for a reason. Fraser firs are loved for their sturdy, upward angled branches that hold heavier ornaments with ease. Their dark green needles create a classic holiday look, and they're known for excellent needle retention. You'll also get a pleasant, natural scent that never feels overwhelming.
Why families choose it:
- Strongest branch structure
- Great for keepsake or weighted ornaments
- Dark, rich color
- Long lasting freshness
- Mild but noticeable fragrance
Available Heights and Prices:
- Up to 5 feet: $32.99
- Up to 6 feet: $64.99
- Up to 7 feet: $84.99
- Up to 8 feet: $99.99
- Cathedral: $219.99 (customer favorite)
Balsam Fir
If fragrance is a priority, the balsam fir is the holiday hero. This variety offers the strongest traditional Christmas tree scent. Its branches are dense and sturdy, with beautiful dark green needles that create a full and festive shape. Balsams give a softer, classic look that many families consider a must for the season.
Why families choose it:
- Most fragrant tree in the bunch
- Dense and full shape
- Strong branches for standard ornaments
- Traditional holiday appearance
Available Heights and Prices:
- Up to 5 feet: $32.99
- Up to 6 feet: $55.99
- Up to 7 feet: $69.99
- Up to 8 feet: $79.99
- Cathedral: $219.99 (customer favorite)
FAQ: Choosing Your Christmas Tree
If you still have a few questions while choosing between a Fraser fir and a balsam fir, you’re not alone. Many shoppers want to know about scent, durability, and which tree works best for their holiday style. These common questions make it easier to feel confident before you head to the lot.
How do I know what size tree to buy?
Measure your ceiling height and subtract about twelve to eighteen inches for the stand and topper. This gives you the ideal tree height for your space.
Which tree is better for heavy ornaments?
The Fraser fir has the strongest branch structure. If you hang keepsakes, glass ornaments, or anything with weight, this is the best pick.
Which tree smells the most like Christmas?
The balsam fir offers the strongest holiday fragrance. If scent is important to you, start there.
Which tree keeps its needles the longest?
Fraser firs are known for excellent needle retention. If you like to keep your tree up into the New Year, this variety typically performs the best.
Are both trees fresh cut?
Yes. Stew Leonard’s trees arrive fresh from trusted growers. We also cut a fresh slice from the trunk when you purchase to help with water absorption.
How often should I water my tree?
Check the stand daily during the first week. A freshly cut tree can drink a lot of water. Keeping the stand full helps your tree stay fresh and green.
What is the difference between a regular tree and a Cathedral tree?
Cathedral trees are premium, extra tall trees with a full shape. They are popular for homes with lofty ceilings or large, open rooms.
Do these trees have natural imperfections?
Yes. Real trees grow in nature and can have slight variations in shape and fullness. Many customers love this because it adds charm and authenticity to holiday decorating.